I don’t look back too fondly of my days in PE (Physical Education) classes back in my k-12 experience.
I’m not sure what exactly I learned. What I do remember is being taunted, being the last to be picked on a team, being yelled at by other team mates by not being very good at something, having to play the opposite gender when they were trying to teach us square dancing because there weren’t enough girls in class, etc.
Indeed, PE was very Darwinian. Survival of the fittest. You get thrown into an activity and hopefully you knew what the heck to do.
Where exactly was the education?
I was fast, flexible, agile, strong for my size, and had pretty good coordination. But PE did not nurture any of these physical attributes.
Contrast this to Martial Arts. It is very regimented. There is a curriculum. You build a solid foundation first on which you get graded, and progressively and incrementally more advanced skills from that, taking tests to demonstrate your progress along the way.
It is a true education. You don’t (or shouldn’t) be told to spar right away. You must prove that you have your fundamentals first. It is always about proving to your teachers that you are ready for the next phase of techniques, drills, etc.
You’re not allowed to take trigonometry if you haven’t passed geometry. You cannot take geometry without having passed algebra. You cannot take algebra if you haven’t demonstrated competency in basic mathematics/pre-algebra.
A Martial arts education works the same way. It is a logical structure that builds upon itself, layer by layer. You are truly learning something.
That’s why anytime someone who is interested in taking martial arts classes from me says that they have done martial arts before, I get excited for them. Generally, a lot of people will say, “But that was such a long time ago, I was just a kid.” But chances are, it was a pretty well structured program that built upon itself. So while you may not remember the specifics of the curriculum, it gave you a solid foundation, that built important physical attributes systematically. Because of this, your ability to learn and grasp the material will be faster (usually) than someone who has not gone through the process.
So could martial arts really ever be part of a public school formal education curriculum? Probably not. It may be seen as teaching violence (which is usually not true), but more importantly, unless it is a sport-martial art like Judo, it is very hard to standardize martial arts, mainly because of the many different styles and politics.
It’s a bit of a paradox, really. For such an organized and structured process of learning, organizationally, martial arts is an administrative mess, as there is no one body of standards. Anyone can claim themselves a master and open a school. That actually makes it good for the private sector economically.
But unfortunately, people miss out on the opportunity because of it. We do however live in a ubiquitous age of information sharing, so it is more accessible now than it has ever been.
And that is exactly why I write these pieces, to help share and spread the over arching benefits of it, explained to people without any experience in a tangible way why this is such a beneficial activity.
So martial arts indeed is a physical education in its logical structure and learning process. It is also a very holistic education, but that is for another post!