The Demon's Sermon on Spears & Kungfu Styles - by Mads Rud

One of my favorite books is Issai Chozanshi's The Demon's Sermon on Martial Arts. I consider it a must read for any scholar-martial artist. After a collection of short stories, we hear of a swordsman's uncanny meeting with a demon in the mountain forests. Chapter 4 starts as such:  

"One of the other demons asked, 'In the traditional teachings on the spear, there is the straight spear, the cross-headed spear, the hook spear, the tube spear, and others. Which of these would be the most advantageous?'"

Every martial artist either has or will hear a similar sentiment. Which style is best for fighting—are traditional styles even useful anymore? Is it best to start with striking, or grappling? That style's kicks don't actually work 'in real life.' As a new practitioner, it's dizzying. How do we pick what's most advantageous? Those who are far enough on their own path may anticipate the demon's answer.

"How can you ask such a stupid question?" Harsh. Mind you, the demon has been talking for three chapters by now. He continues, "The spear is a weapon for thrusting, and complete freedom in thrusting is within yourself, not the instrument. [When a martial artist] has grasped things on his own, even the staff he holds can become a spear for him."

The best style is the one you are going to train enough that can grasp it, and use it to thrust. That thrust could certainly be the use of an actual spear. It could also be fitness, mental wellness, self-efficacy, or even just social connection with a class. I can tell you for sure, though, the best tube spear in the world  is never going to benefit you if you don't practice with it. And just like the spear is meant to be used, a martial art needs to be practiced to find benefit.